A Brief History
On June 4, 2010, attorney Brittney Horstman was prevented from meeting with a client while he was incarcerated at the Miami Federal Detention Center because her underwire bra had set off a metal detector. It was feared that the metal in the bras could be used as a tool to help prisoners hurt themselves or escape or even as a weapon against guards. Ms. Horstman removed her bra in a bathroom but was still barred from entering the Florida prison because she was now braless, a violation of the prison’s dress code. During an investigation of the incident, a memo was found allowing female lawyers wearing underwire bras to enter the prison; however, the guards on duty during Ms. Horstman’s visit were unaware of the modified policy. The incident was concluded to be “an aberration”, and it was promised that it would not happen again.
Digging Deeper
Despite women always having had breasts, the brassiere or “bra” as it is commonly known is practically a modern invention. Although early bras have been found in Austria dating back to between 1440 and 1485, variations of the modern bra were only first introduced in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The interim period had been dominated by the corset, a contraption made of cloth and metal or whalebone which gave the appearance of a small waist and raised the bust.
Though they are not generally known for their sense of fashion, Germans are known for their practicality and ingenuity in design and engineering. With this in mind, it is no surprise that the first modern bra was patented in 1889 by Christine Hardt, a German woman! And later in 1912 Sigmund Lindauer of Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt, Germany, developed the first brassiere for mass production and had it patented in 1913. These bras were of course still somewhat rudimentary in form, and the first design that would now be recognized as a modern bra was patented in 1914 in the United States by Mary Phelps Jacob. Then came World War I, and metal shortages brought upon the end of the corset. With its main competition out of the way, the bra’s time had come!
This year the bra celebrates its 100th anniversary. Though first created as a means of physical support for the bust, it has now become a cultural norm, a symbol of femininity and a girl’s rite of passage into womanhood. So much so, that even flat-chested women who do not need support are encouraged to wear padded bras. But how necessary is a bra really? And can women be forced to wear them? When the author of this article was 9 and began sprouting buds on her chest, she made her mother drive her to the department store to pick out her very first bra. For all intents and purposes, the author did not yet have enough breast volume to even fill an AAA-cup (smallest cup size), but she demanded a bra because she believed that wearing it would help her identify with her mother and as a woman. In other words, it sexualized the young child. From then on, the author continuously wore a bra for the next 24 years, until she sustained a painful lower rib injury which made wearing bras extremely agonizing. So instead of wearing bras, she resorted to wearing undershirts under her tops. To her great surprise, she did not miss her bras. In fact she realized she did not need the support and had only worn the bras because she knew no differently. It was almost as if it had been expected of her, and that she never really had a choice in the matter based off of her own experiences, preferences and needs. Apparently society had dictated those for her.
Now should a woman be forced to wear a bra just a man might be forced to take his hat off in a building? Rulings have been made that companies may enforce a dress code to ensure uniformity of appearance, and other proponents of bra-wearing believe the bras help prevent sagging and help cover the nipples whose appearance might be deemed inappropriate and indecent to some. Granted there are some incidences when a bra is truly warranted, such as in sports and in breastfeeding and with women who are large busted and need the support or else they might develop back pain, but how necessary are bras in cases where less support is needed? And is this any one else’s business other than the woman’s?

Nevertheless, many view bralessness as slovenly, disgusting, unrefined or uncultured. Bras do shape the bustier and give it a pleasant if not sexy form, which might be viewed as aesthetically pleasing. In many ways, a well-shaped bosom has become a standard of beauty. But why is the natural look offensive to some? Or at least offensive enough to block access to public buildings such as prisons? Many women who go braless are judged harshly and even considered trashy. It receives almost as much public disapproval as breast-feeding in public. The author, on the other hand, can attest that if the breasts are not too large and if one wears appropriate clothing, bralessness will not be noticed. Bralessness does not automatically equate to bouncing boobies. It is however important for women who do choose to go braless to try to maintain some degree of tact and class. But what is tackier? – Wearing a tank top with no bra underneath or actually seeing the bra straps or even the clasp sticking out the back of the tank top?! So, you see, it is a matter of how “it” is packaged.
But getting back to the prison that denied entry to Ms. Horstman, how did they ever intend to enforce their stipulation that women wear bras on their premises? They knew Ms. Horstman was not wearing a bra because she actively took it off to gain entry, but in the author’s case, without careful inspection, they would never have noticed that she was not wearing a bra, so did they also have a pat down policy to ensure adherence to code? They are just boobs, people! In fact, at many detention facilities women are not even allowed to wear bras.

There are also some medical advantages to going braless. Bras that are too tight can obstruct flow of the lymph nodes, which may increase the risk of breast cancer. This risk comes about because the lymphatic vessels are thin and extremely sensitive to pressure and are easily compressed, meaning that less oxygen and fewer nutrients are delivered to the cells, and waste products are not flushed away. And for those of you who say that this is a ridiculous and unfounded myth, breast cancer and the lymph nodes of the arm are closely interrelated. Many women who have had mastectomies need to see specialized masseuses to manually have the lymph drained from them because it is common practice to remove the lymph nodes which are located in their armpits as well, as these are body parts to which the cancer oftentimes first spreads. Furthermore, when going braless, the straps and hooks can no longer dig into the skin and cause friction rubbing and open sores and wounds. On an aesthetic level, it is nice to wear tops without the outline of the bra and its straps underneath, which allows for a softer and less constrained appearance.
Bras have also long been viewed as a symbol of feminine oppression and going braless as a symbol of feminine expression. The 1960s experienced the bra-burning movement (this occurred symbolically rather than physically). And presently the women’s rights group Femen often stages topless protests at political conventions and public events. Their reasons for going topless, however, are less political in themselves, but rather so that they will be seen (and hopefully then heard).

And contrary to many men believing there are either “butt-men” or “boob-men”, depending on preference, most men are actually in fact “butt-men”. The popularity of the bra, especially the Wonderbra lies in ability to create the semblance of a small butt on the chest. Go ahead and truly take a good look at a full rack that has been squeezed together into a nice-looking cleavage. It really looks like a butt! Men have been biologically programmed since their cavemen days to like butts, as it is generally believed that “doggy-style” was the first sexual position practiced by mankind. And after all that imagery, you’ll probably never look at cleavage the same way again…
At any rate, the author does not feel any less feminine for going braless. She made an informed decision based off her current needs and preferences; however, should she one day decide to wear a bra again, she is happy for this option. As for Brittney Horstman, she probably never thought that in her professional field, her 15 minutes of fame would come from going braless. This example goes to show just how powerful a fixture in modern society the bra has become and just how it defines a woman’s femininity, sexuality and others’ perception of her. And despite what society may want, a woman’s breasts are there for herself and her children and not for others!
Question for students (and subscribers): Should bra-less attorneys be barred from entering prisons? Please let us know in the comments section below this article.
If you liked this article and would like to receive notification of new articles, please feel welcome to subscribe to History and Headlines by liking us on Facebook and becoming one of our patrons!
Your readership is much appreciated!
Historical Evidence
For more information on the history of bras, please see…
Berry, Cheree. Hoorah for the Bra: A Perky Peek at the History of the Brassiere. Harry N. Abrams, 2006.
Fontanel, Beatrice. Support and Seduction: A History of Corsets and Bras. Harry N Abrams Inc, 1997.
<span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="2499 http://www.crackedhistory.com/?p=2499">21 Comments
Honestly, who the heck cares if women wear a bra or not. Now I know some females feel “naked” without one, or they think it makes them look more sexy but in reality guys do not really care, so if the female is wearing it she is doing it for herself and not the guy. Guys like it both ways in my opinion. But about the prison, i can see why they would not want wire being brought into the prison but really? You think a lawyer is gonna dissassemble her bra for a convict? Come on now lets have some common sense people.
Dear Kirk, Thanks for commenting on my article. It is refreshing and reassuring to get this sort of “support” from a man. You are correct; women do many things for men aside from wearing a bra because they believe it is what the guy wants, when in reality he couldn’t care less. And in many cases, the guy does not even notice. Here’s a secret for you: many women consider men shallow and demanding when it comes to our appearance because that is the image we project onto them. In reality, it’s us women making it hard on ourselves by going down more extreme beauty avenues and by holding ourselves to standards we may not always be able to uphold.
I found this article very interesting. I never really thought about the reasons behind wearing a bra. It was a part of growing up. When I was young I just thought it was something a woman had to do. I never thought anything else of it. We all just wanted to fit in with the other girls. I think our culture set a standard for women. Now, thinking more about this, I believe that it should be the choice of the woman herself to wear or not to wear a bra.
Dear Lindsey, Thanks for your support and understanding 🙂 I believe you are the first female to comment on this article (no offense to any other who might have, but I couldn’t tell by the name). Just as our culture determined that I should wear a bra for the first 24 years of my “womanhood”, I am happy that I now have the choice to decide what I want for myself for the rest of it.
As Kirk said I too believe women wearing or not wearing a bra is not a issue. Men and women should not worry about what certain articles of clothing will portray them as. I believe the woman should wear one if she enjoys it and it is to her comfort, if not then don’t.
Dear Zach, Thank you for reading my article and taking the time to respond. And thank you for also confirming that many men simply don’t care about such things as women going braless. In many ways we women are our own worst enemies; we judge and criticize one another for things that would never cross a man’s mind. It has mostly always been women giving each other a hard time for such superficial things such as fashion.
Personally, I do not mind either way. The example of the lawyer was ridiculous; the guards in the prison could obviously keep an eye on the situation and prevent the female attorney from disassembling here bra in public and handing the wire to the prisoner.
I do think a woman will always be expected to wear a bra in public and in the professional world. The traditional has been around for too long to be changed at this point, in my opinion. Please let me know if you agree or disagree, I appreciate your time!
Dear Paul, Thank you for your comment. In my own experience in an international professional field as a manager, I do not believe anyone noticed my bralessness. Of course, I didn’t just let it all hang out or wear thin blouses; I dressed appropriately and with taste. And I still try to stay respectful and non-offensive. As for tradition, I have learned to do what is best for me and feel very blessed to have choices. I will no longer do as society dictates, especially since me not wearing a bra isn’t hurting anyone. Life is too short.
As some of the guys had posted, they don’t care if women go braless or not but I feel that is not the case for women. I think women judge other women who are going braless in public. I think it is ridiculous that the guards did not allow the lawyer in when she removed her bra especially if you could not tell. If it was noticeable, I would understand that depending on who the lawyer was going to talk to, it could be more problematic that she was braless and it was noticeable. Like I previously said, I think there are judgements made when women go braless in public.
Dear Mo, You are entirely correct in your assumption that it’s primarily women who judge other women, though I haven’t quite figured out why this is the case – maybe competition? jealousy? Perhaps they feel threatened? It likely has something to do with female insecurities.
I have to say I chuckled a bit after reading that this lawyer was denied access to her client not once but twice. I found it interesting that this has now just happened see that woman have been wearing bras since they have manufactured in 1914. I also laughed when she took of the braw but was still denied access to her client. I find it weird that they didn’t let her in because just like the mentioned its like men wearing a hat and taking it off before they go somewhere. I though that was an interesting read as well as the videos that went with it.
Dear KC, I’m happy you found my article an interesting read 🙂 The video poster will also be happy to hear he did a good job 😉 Your comment is very much appreciated. Please stop by regularly for many more interesting reads from both me and my co-writers.
This was a very interesting article. I think it shows how our society today over reacts about everything. Common sense would show most people that it would have been fine to let her through after she removed the bra. Ethier way very interesting read.
I found it very odd that the woman was not allowed into the prison because of her bra and when she tried to take it off and then go in, she was still denied. This was an interesting read and the points about women not having to wear a bra a valid.
Dear HO, Thank you for taking the time to read my article. I am happy you found it interesting and that you believe the arguments presented in support of women having a choice without fear of scrutiny on whether to wear a bra or not are valid.
Personally, I would rather wear a bra than go braless just because it makes me feel more comfortable that way, but either way it doesn’t matter to me if other people decide to or not. With the lawyer I can only imagine how that must of been embarrassing for her, but interesting article nevertheless!
After being braless for nearly two years, I can honestly say I don’t miss bras. I can also add that my chest feels more free and less confined and constricted and that my breasts have not suffered at all. Just know that in case you ever have to surrender your bra, you’ll be just fine 😉
Player of the game is called the Pokemon Trainer, generally, there are two goals for such Trainer,
one is to complete the Pok. But rest assured, paying an extra buck for
an article of clothing that will last for years is certainty worth
it. However, you probably already know that the Seagallop that leaves out of Vermillion City.
Feel free to surf to my blog; pokemon x and y rom [wordpress.com]
What a wonderful article! 🙂
Featuring the newest trend in bras, ( La Bralette ) No under wires or pesky hooks stabbing you in the back, yuck! These are non constricting unlike most undergarments still sold in stores today. These are wonderful it’s like your not even wearing anything! Awsome right? They come in all sizes, colors and fabrics, as you can see in my photo below are very sexy as well! Though I would love to go braless , I unfortunately risk the chance of the occasional “flop out” and although many would love to catch a glimpse of a woman’s ” Accidental nipple” their are some that wouldn’t! The perfect alternative to those ” Evil outdated bolder holders”
🙂
Dear Reggie, Thank you for the pic of “la bralette.” For me it’s still too much bra, but it does look very nice.