Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Tuesday, October 3
    Trending
    • This Day in History on October 3rd
    • History Short: Who Are the Greatest Set of Baseball Brothers?
    • This Day in History on October 2nd
    • History Short: Let Us Help You Name Your Car!
    • This Day in History on October 1st
    • History Short: EPCOT Center Opens at Walt Disney World
    • This Day in History on September 30th
    • History Short: The Most Historic World Series Ever?
    History and Headlines
    • Arts & Entertainment
      • Cinema & TV
      • Games
      • Literature
      • Music
      • Sports
      • Video Games
    • Bizarre Bulletin
      • Misconceptions
      • The Bizarre
      • The Paranormal
      • The Unexplained
    • Lifestyle
      • Animals/Pets
      • Fashion
      • Food
      • Health/Medicine
      • Home Improvement
      • Horoscopes
      • Travel
    • Science & Tech
      • Inventions
      • Nature
      • Vehicles
    • Society
      • Business and Economics
      • Crime
      • Military
      • Politics
      • Religion
      • Society
    • About
      • Welcome to Our Site!
      • This Day in History (articles)
      • This Day in History (categories)
      • Table of Contents: A History of the World
      • Online History Textbooks
      • A Guide to Some of Our Favorite Scholars and Educators
      • Advance Screenings and Movie Reviews Archive
      • Schedule of Video Adaptations of Our Articles
    • Friends
      • Armchair History TV
      • Fact Fiend
      • RealClearHistory
      • Simply Charly
      • TopTenz
      • ​Unique Interpretations
    History and Headlines
    You are at:Home»April»April 25»History vs. Hollywood: The Philip Experiment vs. The Quiet Ones
    April 25

    History vs. Hollywood: The Philip Experiment vs. The Quiet Ones

    Dr. ZarBy Dr. ZarApril 25, 2014Updated:March 14, 202026 Comments3 Mins Read
    Email Facebook LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit Telegram Tumblr Twitter VKontakte WhatsApp

    A Brief History

    On April 25, 2014, The Quiet Ones will be released in American theaters.  The film purports to be inspired by actual events, but to what extent does the movie recreate these so-called “actual events”?

    Digging Deeper

    In the 1970s, real-life Dr. Alan Robert George Owen created the Toronto Society for Psychical Research.  According to journalists Ryan and Louise Hung, this group consisted of eight adult men and women who invented a fictional  aristocrat named Philip Aylesford.  This fake man lived centuries ago and achieved infamy for cheating on his wife with a Gypsy.  The angry wife then accused the Gypsy of witchcraft, resulting in her execution by being burned alive.  All of this background story was intended to make Philip as lifelike as possible.  Why?  Well, the group’s goal was to see if paranormal activity could be created by the group’s psychic power out of belief in something rather than by the existence of actual spirits.  The group held seances in which they called upon Philip to show signs of his presence, which the group claims this fictitious deceased person did in fact do at the group’s behest.  Fortunately, the group recorded their “evidence” of what occurred, including levitating tables and weird knocking sounds.  You can judge for yourself if what you are seeing is really something paranormal or an elaborate hoax.

    Beyond the whole paranormal experiment taking place in the 1970s, the movie takes just about everything else in an entirely different direction with no real historic basis.  Instead of a group of Canadians making up a man and conducting relatively lighthearted experiments, the film’s characters conduct much more frightening experiments concerning a living young woman plagued by strange phenomenon.  The film further brings in other bizarre elements ranging from a mysterious cult that died in a fire to an ancient goddess possessing a little girl.  One need only watch the video footage of the Philip Experiment and then see the trailer for The Quite Ones to see how profoundly different the film is from its alleged historic inspiration.

    These are not little minor changes in character names, for example, but rather the majority of the movie is the invention of the filmmakers.  Question for students (and subscribers): That does not necessarily take away from the movie as an effective horror film, but what do you think?  Is it fair to claim inspiration from historical events when the movie is so much different from what actually occurred?  Also, do you think the Philip Experiment was a genuine successful display of human psychic power or a hoax?  Please let us know in the comments section below this article.

    If you liked this article and would like to receive notification of new articles, please feel welcome to subscribe to History and Headlines by liking us on Facebook and becoming one of our patrons!

    Your readership is much appreciated!

    Historical Evidence

    For the broader context of the Philip Experiment in paranormal history, please read…

    Aykroyd, Peter H. and Angela Narth.  A History of Ghosts: The True Story of Séances, Mediums, Ghosts, and Ghostbusters.  Rodale Books, 2009.

    For more on the paranormal, please visit the John Carroll University Paranormal Research Group.  As can be seen on Facebook, the group will be among the first Americans to see the film this week!

    Share. Email Facebook LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit Telegram Twitter Tumblr
    Previous Article10 Great Things About Teddy Roosevelt
    Next Article 10 Bizarre Injuries to Athletes
    Dr. Zar
    • Website

    Dr. Zar graduated with a B.A. in French and history, a Master’s in History, and a Ph.D. in History. He currently teaches history in Ohio.

    Related Posts

    History Short: Who Are the Greatest Set of Baseball Brothers?

    October 3, 2023

    History Short: EPCOT Center Opens at Walt Disney World

    October 1, 2023

    History Short: The Most Historic World Series Ever?

    September 30, 2023

    <span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="1943 http://www.crackedhistory.com/?p=1943">26 Comments

    1. Deanna Nagle on April 26, 2014 10:30 pm

      I think that most of the time the paranormal claims made are just made up whether or not the person means to. I do believe that the paranormal is real though.

      Reply
    2. Kristin Schlabach on April 27, 2014 5:41 pm

      I don’t believe there’s any way a fake person that these people created could have possibly showed up during their seances. Even if this person actually would have existed in the past, I still don’t believe their seances could have brought him back so they could somehow feel his presence. I do, however, very much believe in the presence of evil. I believe that demons are real, and so are angels. If these people actually did experience strange happenings and shaking of tables and such, it was only because satanic powers were being used.

      Reply
    3. Ashton on April 27, 2014 7:03 pm

      I personally hate horror movies. Evil is a very real thing and I believe that there are demons, I don’t believe that a human being can create another human and then call him back later.

      Reply
    4. Hannah Zorger on April 27, 2014 9:17 pm

      demons can be real, yes the individual did experience something weird, evil powers were being used. But who really knows! but i don’t think a human can personally call back another though. but everything is up in the air

      Reply
    5. jprokay on April 28, 2014 11:20 am

      i think that it is fine to take references from events the only thing that i would have to say is for them not to say and stress that it came from real events because if it was real it should be really close to the actual events not just parts from it. but other then that the movie really was great.

      Reply
    6. Jessica Savage on April 28, 2014 1:23 pm

      I think it is okay to gain inspiration from historical events but not to say that things are based off of them if the story is so much different. The experiment was extraordinary to say the least. I can’t say whether I believe that it was a spirit or some sort of psychic power but considering the experiment has been duplicated I could see how having possible unknown psychic abilities could be the reason behind the strange phenomena.

      Reply
    7. dane schwartz on April 28, 2014 7:28 pm

      I love horror movies but I 100 percent agree with Deanna on this one.

      Reply
    8. ML on April 28, 2014 10:44 pm

      Quite interesting. I do believe in the paranormal but I agree with others that most cases of paranormal activity are faked, whether the people were directly involved or not. It would be a movie I’d check out, probably in the dollar theater.

      Reply
    9. Hannah Brewer on April 29, 2014 11:16 am

      I am a huge fan of horror movies, so I found this article very interesting. It would be awesome if it were actually true!

      Reply
    10. Benkuhn on April 29, 2014 3:16 pm

      This is a good article and i love to see when new movies come out on cool events that happened and hopefully it is not fake.

      Reply
    11. Autumn Harmon on April 29, 2014 10:14 pm

      I hate horror movies, so this article was one of my least favorites. So I would not go and watch this.

      Reply
    12. KM on April 29, 2014 11:31 pm

      I do not think it is fair to claim historical inspiration unless the film follows an actual event more closely. I also agree that what happened was likely faked, but that if something like this were to happen, it would be demonic.

      Reply
    13. Samantha Carson on May 8, 2014 5:01 pm

      I think that it is interesting what actors think are historically inspired. But a lot of movies say this when they say “inspired by true events” this never means the entire movie is true. Just that one little piece of it is. And typically that piece is altered like in this example.

      Reply
    14. Skippy the Impaler on October 22, 2014 8:20 am

      The writer asks,”Is it fair to claim inspiration from historical events when the movie is so much different from what actually occurred?” And I’d have to say that it’s fair to claim “inspiration” from anything for anything. If I write a story about a slasher who collects tongues and claim I was “inspired” by watching the Teletubbies, who can say that’s not true? I know at least three different film-makers have claimed that their horror movies were inspired by Ed Gein and I’ll be darned if I can figure out what any one of their works has to do with Gein.

      Reply
    15. Alex Guthrie on December 5, 2015 12:48 pm

      The Phillip Experiment appears to be nothing but a hoax.

      Reply
    16. Olivia on December 7, 2015 2:18 pm

      The fact hollywood can be so inaccurate when it comes to the real historical story makes it hard for me to believe in the “real thing”

      Reply
    17. Lauren Mangan on December 7, 2015 7:43 pm

      That’s a very interesting idea for a movie I wish Hollywood would present it similar to the actual study however I understand if they need to make it more exciting to have and audience

      Reply
    18. Sammi DiGeronimo on December 7, 2015 10:51 pm

      Aside from the completely messed up story that Hollywood tried to portray as “actual events,” I really want to see the Quiet Ones now because I’m a huge horror movie fan.

      Reply
    19. Connor Lynch on December 8, 2015 9:21 pm

      Sadly, history doesn’t often make for a good movie. Its understandable that directors have to stray from the true narrative in order to gain mass appeal and turn a profit.

      Reply
    20. KR on December 9, 2015 11:47 pm

      I’m not sure they can claim inspiration from the historical event at that point, but who knows? As Skippy already pointed out. inspiration can be a funny thing and doesn’t always necessarily make sense looking in from the outside.

      Reply
    21. Dan Hennessey on December 11, 2015 10:58 am

      They movie makers defiantly appeared to spruce up the story line and dramatize certain aspects.

      Reply
    22. Thomas Robinson on December 16, 2015 8:59 pm

      Quiet Ones looks interesting. Sometimes you have to take creative liberty to make real life events more exciting.

      Reply
    23. Salih Saritoprak on December 17, 2015 1:03 pm

      I love horror movies so I actually knew most of the things they talked about in this article

      Reply
    24. Alexa V on December 17, 2015 6:34 pm

      Honestly a story/movie about a man cheating on his wife with a gypsy could be something out of a TLC show and it does not surprise me at all that the story has been spruced up.

      Reply
    25. N Sword on December 18, 2015 12:39 am

      I think it is fair when filmmakers and other artists make drastic changes to their adaptions of stories. Since everyone has a unique perspective on these kinds of subjects, it is interesting to see different takes on the same story.

      Reply
    26. SK on December 18, 2015 1:10 am

      LOL at Alexa V’s comment. Agree with her. I will give this movie a chance even though I am terrified by scary movies.

      Reply

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Follow Us!
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
    • Patreon
    Sign Up For Our Newsletter!
    Most Recent

    This Day in History on October 3rd

    October 3, 2023

    History Short: Who Are the Greatest Set of Baseball Brothers?

    October 3, 2023

    This Day in History on October 2nd

    October 2, 2023

    History Short: Let Us Help You Name Your Car!

    October 2, 2023

    This Day in History on October 1st

    October 1, 2023
    This Day in History Video

    Advertisements




    Amazon Affiliate Disclosure Statement

    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases via links in the “Historical Evidence” sections of articles.

    About HistoryAndHeadlines.com

    Thanks for visiting History and Headlines!  This site exists primarily for educational purposes and is intended as a resource for Dr. Zar’s students.  Articles are mostly written by either Dr. Zar or his dad (Major Dan).  To any guest readers, please keep that in mind when commenting on articles.   Thank you!

    We try to present our students with historical topics that are both diverse and a bit out of the ordinary.  Our motto is “We try until we succeed!”

    Contact us at admin@historyandheadlines.com

    Guidelines and Policies for Images used on This Site, as well as for Guest and Sponsored Articles, and Other Terms of Use

    Privacy Statement

    © 2023 History and Headlines

    All-Time Most Commented

    July 28, 1866: 18 Year Old Girl Wins Commission to Sculpt Statue of Lincoln (A Truly Great American Woman)

    July 28, 2014

    December 24, 1865: Birth of the Ku Klux Klan

    December 24, 2015

    December 25, 1868: President Johnson Pardons all Confederate Veterans

    December 25, 2015

    February 5, 1909: First Plastic Invented was called Bakelite!

    February 5, 2014

    November 23, 1876: “Boss” Tweed Turned Over to Authorities

    November 23, 2013
    Recommended Book
    © 2023 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

    You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in .

    History and Headlines
    Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

    Strictly Necessary Cookies

    Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

    If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.