Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Friday, February 3
    Trending
    • February 3, 2023: Some Questions on this Week’s News
    • This Day in History on February 3rd
    • History Short: The Most Important Naval Battle You Never Heard Of
    • This Day in History on February 2nd
    • History Short: What Else is February 2nd Known For?
    • Triumphs and Tragedies of the Space Shuttle Program: A Compilation
    • This Day in History on February 1st
    • History Short: Who is America’s Greatest Male Actor?
    History and Headlines
    • Arts & Entertainment
      • Cinema & TV
      • Games
      • Literature
      • Music
      • Sports
      • Video Games
    • Bizarre Bulletin
      • Misconceptions
      • The Bizarre
      • The Paranormal
      • The Unexplained
    • Lifestyle
      • Animals/Pets
      • Fashion
      • Food
      • Health/Medicine
      • Home Improvement
      • Horoscopes
      • Travel
    • Science & Tech
      • Inventions
      • Nature
      • Vehicles
    • Society
      • Business and Economics
      • Crime
      • Military
      • Politics
      • Religion
      • Society
    • About
      • Welcome to Our Site!
      • This Day in History
      • Table of Contents: A History of the World
      • Online History Textbooks
      • A Guide to Some of Our Favorite Scholars and Educators
      • Advance Screenings and Movie Reviews Archive
      • Schedule of Video Adaptations of Our Articles
    • Friends
      • Armchair History TV
      • Fact Fiend
      • RealClearHistory
      • Simply Charly
      • TopTenz
      • ​Unique Interpretations
    History and Headlines
    You are at:Home»April»April 20»April 20, 1818: Murderer Goes Free on “Trial by Combat” Clause
    April 20

    April 20, 1818: Murderer Goes Free on “Trial by Combat” Clause

    Major DanBy Major DanApril 20, 2015Updated:April 13, 20215 Comments4 Mins Read
    Email Facebook LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit Telegram Tumblr Twitter VKontakte WhatsApp
    Abraham Thornton

    A Brief History   

    On April 20, 1818, accused British murderer Abraham Thornton was set free after his accuser refused to fight him in a “trial by combat.” 

    Digging Deeper

    Thornton had walked a girl home from a dance, and the next day the girl was found drowned in a pit.  Thornton was charged with murder but was acquitted at trial.  This is where things begin to get a bit different from the American idea of due process.  As was his right based on an archaic English law, the brother of the dead girl, however, insisted that Thornton be retried.   Thornton, however, invoked another medieval English law that allowed accused murderers, traitors and other felons the option of trial by combat in cases of retrial. 

    The accuser, a William Ashford, had demanded the retrial on the grounds of overwhelming evidence and thought therefore that trial by combat was unnecessary, but the judge ruled the evidence not so “overwhelming” and granted the trial by combat.  Just four years previously, a judge in Ireland had refused to entertain the idea.  For his part, Ashford declined the opportunity to engage his sister’s alleged murderer in combat, and Thornton was thus freed.  Just one year later, in 1819, the British Parliament repealed the outdated law.  Thornton would move to the United States and died in 1860. 

    It is unclear as to when the last fight in lieu of trial took place, with possible last cases in the 1630s.  The last cases known to have taken place with certainty were in Scotland in 1597 where the accused murderer was killed in battle and in England in 1446 where a servant killed his master. 

    Trial by battle was not afforded everyone, as those caught in the act or with overwhelming evidence against them would have to stand conventional trial anyway.  No option to battle it out was given to accused persons who had tried to escape or if the accuser was a woman over 60, a minor or a handicapped person.  Interestingly, noblemen and citizens of London were exempt from having to do battle with the accused.  Another rule was that if the defendant was beaten in battle but did not die, he was to be hanged immediately.

    Not only could an accuser (plaintiff) also be killed in battle, but if both combatants were still alive after 24 hours of battle or if the accuser admitted defeat by uttering the word  “craven,” the defendant would be declared innocent and the accuser would be declared “infamous” and lose his rights as a freeman and be stuck with a bill for damages.  It seems this rule was instated to prevent accusers from making frivolous and unfounded accusations.

    Attempts to repeal this medieval law before 1819 had been met with defeat, with proponents proclaiming the right to a judicial duel a “great pillar of the constitution.”

    Question for students (and subscribers): What do you think of the concept of trial by combat?  Remember, it was only offered as a second trial following an acquittal.  It certainly does have an air of gallantry about it as depicted in movies and television productions such as HBO’s Game of Thrones.  Do you wish this option were still legal?  Please let us know your thoughts in the comments section below this article.  

    If you liked this article and would like to receive notification of new articles, please feel welcome to subscribe to History and Headlines by liking us on Facebook and becoming one of our patrons!

    Your readership is much appreciated!

    Historical Evidence

    For more information, please see…

    Neilson, George.  Trial by Combat.  The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd., 2009.

    The featured image in this article, a contemporary depiction of Abraham Thornton, was published before January 1, 1926 and it is anonymous or pseudonymous due to unknown authorship. It is in the public domain in the United States as well as countries and areas where the copyright terms of anonymous or pseudonymous works are 95 years or fewer since publication.

    You can also watch a video version of this article on YouTube.

    Share. Email Facebook LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit Telegram Twitter Tumblr
    Previous ArticleHistory vs. Hollywood: Unfriended (Cybernatural)
    Next Article Catherine Parr, Henry VIII’s Forgotten Wife
    Major Dan

    Major Dan is a retired veteran of the United States Marine Corps. He served during the Cold War and has traveled to many countries around the world. Prior to his military service, he graduated from Cleveland State University, having majored in sociology. Following his military service, he worked as a police officer eventually earning the rank of captain prior to his retirement.

    Related Posts

    History Short: The Most Important Naval Battle You Never Heard Of

    February 3, 2023

    History Short: What Poison Gasses were Used in World War I?

    January 31, 2023

    History Short: What is the Axis of Evil?

    January 29, 2023
    Follow Us!
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
    • Patreon
    Sign Up For Our Newsletter!
    Most Recent

    February 3, 2023: Some Questions on this Week’s News

    February 3, 2023

    This Day in History on February 3rd

    February 3, 2023

    History Short: The Most Important Naval Battle You Never Heard Of

    February 3, 2023

    This Day in History on February 2nd

    February 2, 2023

    History Short: What Else is February 2nd Known For?

    February 2, 2023
    This Day in History Video

    Advertisements




    Amazon Affiliate Disclosure Statement

    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases via links in the “Historical Evidence” sections of articles.

    About HistoryAndHeadlines.com

    Thanks for visiting History and Headlines!  This site exists primarily for educational purposes and is intended as a resource for Dr. Zar’s students.  Articles are mostly written by either Dr. Zar or his dad (Major Dan).  To any guest readers, please keep that in mind when commenting on articles.   Thank you!

    We try to present our students with historical topics that are both diverse and a bit out of the ordinary.  Our motto is “We try until we succeed!”

    Contact us at admin@historyandheadlines.com

    Guidelines and Policies for Images used on This Site, as well as for Guest and Sponsored Articles, and Other Terms of Use

    Privacy Statement

    © 2022 History and Headlines

    All-Time Most Commented

    July 28, 1866: 18 Year Old Girl Wins Commission to Sculpt Statue of Lincoln (A Truly Great American Woman)

    July 28, 2014

    December 24, 1865: Birth of the Ku Klux Klan

    December 24, 2015

    December 25, 1868: President Johnson Pardons all Confederate Veterans

    December 25, 2015

    February 5, 1909: First Plastic Invented was called Bakelite!

    February 5, 2014

    November 23, 1876: “Boss” Tweed Turned Over to Authorities

    November 23, 2013
    Recommended Book
    © 2023 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

    You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings.

    History and Headlines
    Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

    Strictly Necessary Cookies

    Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

    If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.